It was very interesting talking to
Benjamin Reiss in class on Thursday and later that evening. I was
surprised to find that he did not receive any backlash from what he
wrote about. I thought for sure someone from the medical community
or even the minority groups that he was exposing would have something
to say about his work. After describing how he went about his
research and his writing it made more sense to me. Rather than
rehashing the story and re-exploiting the people he was researching
he paid special attention to how he told their story. The way he
approaches his work, as a story teller and not a scientist allows for
him to ask questions not typical of questions asked in articles about
science. Reiss' approach gives the “freaks” a story out of the
public eye.
His talk Thursday night brought up
more interesting points about race and sleep. He showed an image
from the Civil War era that showed a white women in bed. He said
that white people and slave masters often slept. This made me think
about Gone with the Wind and
how during the war Scarlet, the main character, is always being taken
care of because she has slaves. After the war when she doesn't have
any slaves she is still working to get back to Tara, her plantation.
She increasingly becomes depressed throughout the film and must rest
often. While the slaves earlier in the film were being worked to the
bone they didn't have time to take bed rest. Sleep became a sign of
affluence. If someone could sleep often it meant that they did not
have to work; that they had slaves to do it. In class as we
discussed how simple things in life like head shape gets medicalized,
Reiss took it a step further and made us all think about how sleep
can be used to control other people.
I was also surprised that there was no backlash against his writing. It seems like he does write about somewhat "touchy" subjects but he does it in a way where you sort of get to see both sides to the story.
ReplyDeleteAt first, Doctor Reiss' research appeared asinine to me. I originally didn't think that there would be any correlation between sleep and slavery. But, as he went on in his presentation, it became very evident that sleep was a major element of American slavery. I, too, thought his point about sleep as a luxury was quite fascinating. I never looked at sleep in that way. I always thought that slave masters would want their slaves to be well rested for optimal field efficiency.
ReplyDeleteI was surprised about the same thing actually. I mean he is a very good speaker, and it seems like, he is a great writer too. His writing is very invoking and thought-provoking. He really likes people to think about what he is saying/writing.
ReplyDeleteI also find it interesting about the whole sleep control thing. I don't really see your argument/point about Gone with the Wind and sleep control. I will never look at sleep the same way again- I won't take it for granted at least.