Saturday, February 23, 2013

Thursday's discussion

I thought Meghan's discussion on Thursday was fantastic. I love the Gloria Steinem piece on menstruation and I think it relates to this class and the Lorber reading very well. I thought we had an awesome class discussion and it was interesting to see different points of view.

There were a few things in class that were brought up that I'd like to expand on. Someone had made a comment along the lines of "it seems like some things try to make women seem better than men." (Not an exact quote, but something to that regard.) I just wanted to clear up any confusion that people may have about feminism. Having feminist beliefs does not mean that you want to out do men by any means. It just recognizes that there is still inequality between the genders and it tries to create equal access to power and resources for women and girls. Like we said in class, we're still talking about these issues because things still are not equal. It's a shame that stereotypes can ruin an image, a belief system, or a group of people.



Other interesting points made in class was that the poem was satire and pointed only to "what ifs". I do think that theory is needed to work through these important issues, and that we can't just complain about things but need to actually do something about them. But, to start, thinking about what ifs allows us to shatter the norms and get inspired to enact social change. Those what ifs can be the starting point to allow people to say "Hey, that would be better wouldn't it? Let's see what we can do about it." Obviously, we can't make men menstruate, but we can start to think how menstruation, pregnancy, birth, abortion- a lot of things, really- are medicalized and stigmatized in our society and how certain language and practices related to these personal things can be really damaging to women. We can shatter the norms and shift ways of thinking away from the traditional systems, if we decide that those systems don't work anymore. I'm sure a lot of social movements, experiments and interventions started with a "what if?"

I came across this really great blog recently, and she talks about a lot of these issues facing women and how certain things are stigmatized and can be very damaging. The link is http://www.womanstats.org/blog10.htm, and she has a post specifically on menstruation. She talks about a lot of what we said in class- how shame and secrecy surrounding it can have harmful effects on girls and women, and she debunks myths about menstruation that people have held for years. It proves that we can't just "get over it" and "embrace it" as much as we want to. Unfortunately, we live in a society that does not often allow women to just "be themselves" without there being some consequences.

Along with menstruation, pregnancy and birth are very much stigmatized in our society, and many places do not have the respect for pregnant women that they should. Yes, men also risk losing their jobs if they take leave from work. But they usually have the choice. Women, since they physically are the ones who give birth, need to take maternity leave, and often times are not guaranteed their jobs when they return. We are also one of the only countries that does not have paid maternity leave! (See pictures below)



It's just a shame that after all these years, we are still fighting for equality, and that women get punished for natural bodily functions that we have no control over. 






Mutter Museum Documentary

After watching the documentary on the Mutter Museum, besides being a little queasy, I thought a lot about one of the questions that came up, whether the purpose of the museum in modern time is more so for education or entertainment.  I think that it is a little bit of both.  Obviously the artifacts or the models in the museum are used to display medical conditions before we knew anything about them and before medical advancements and discoveries were made.  Over time, relevant artifacts have been collected but I think that the reason the museum is still in business is because we need to take into consideration how much has changed since these discoveries were first made.  Part of this course is observing how different groups were once put in a different kind of light, and observing groups as "freaks", when today, that may not be the case at all. It teaches us how points of views have changed over time and how different the modern world is.  It teaches us how many advancements have been made and that things have changed for the better.  There are things we still may not understand, but we have certainly heard of many of the medical cases or simply individual characteristics and we don't take into account how it was viewed decades, even centuries ago.  I think the museum still stands because it does serve as a source of entertainment but it really opens up your eyes to the history of medicine, authority, and oppression.

Blazing a Trail in Male Sports

There have always been stereotypes about certain sports being a boys world or it's to rough for girls to play. In this years NFL combine that runs from January until April allowing scouts for the 32 pro teams to look at the top kids coming out of college. This years NFL combine is different then any of the ones in the past years. The reason being is that in this years combine there is the first female athlete competing in it. Lauren Silberman a native of New York City will complete in this years regional combine.

Now she may end up being the best kicker at the NFL combine. Or she may be just average. The problem is that I don't think any team will pick her regardless of how well she ends up doing. I feel that the reason teams would not pick her is because the media would lable it as a publicity stunt, a way to get more fans in the seats.

She is attempting to break the sex barrier by becomeing the first female to enter the NFL combine and hopefully be drafted. But because the NFL is a "mans sport" the chances of this seem unlikely. Even if she does not get drafted this year she will still be the first step in getting women into leagues like the NFL. No matter what happens come the draft at the end of April, this will be a historic moment for both the NFL and women.

Dealing with the gender issue through politics

During our discussion on Thursday, someone asked a question stating: If we all have the same ideas about gender inequality and gender roles, and we feel that action needs to be taken, why has nothing changed? Well, if you take a look at who controls the House in our government you will see why. The majority of GOP representatives are white males. If you reflect on the 2012 presidential campaign, it is obvious that these issues that women experience because of their attained characteristics due to their body type, are just as prominent as they were years ago. Equal work, equal pay still doesn't exist in the work force, and questions about whether or not women should be able to do with their body what they want are still in play. Take the Republican nominee, Romney, for example. He presented speeches and plans that showed how he views the gender roles of our society. From using women as a special interest group, to attempting to gain back women voters by stating how he wants pay equity for them, which just ended up into a gaffe (binders full of women) blown up by the media; some say that Romney seemed to use women to his advantage to gain the attention of voters and benefit himself. It is obvious that the gender stereotypes have been so intertwined and cemented into our ideology that attempting to change them via the government just turns into a really biased and in this case, tough and awkward situation. However, there is no doubt that our country is working to fix the gender inequality. We have lifted the ban on combat for women and have broken a record for having 20 women in the Senate, one being openly gay. Similar to our country's race and ethnic issue, the gender inequality issue has not dissipated because of these few significant breakthroughs. We still see unfairness not only in jobs, the media, and politics, but in everyday facilities and situations, as well. Some may argue that women are not at a disadvantage because they have the option to be just as successful, if not more, than men; but that doesn't mean that the issue has been eliminated. Do you think the gender issue will be completely irrelevant in future years because of the progress we have been making?

Friday, February 22, 2013

In response to JWelch's post "A gendered 'fit' body"

This post is in response to JWelch's post as well as based on ideas I had while listening to discussion in class.

While I agree that women and men certainly have the right to do whatever they want in sculpting their bodies, the specific "fit" body assigned to them by society has origins in biology. Men want to build muscle because they have been conditioned to by thousands of years of evolution. To defend themselves, defeat competition for mates, and to gather food men needed muscle; the more muscle one had the better chance you had of surviving. This was the role traditionally assigned to men. Women, on the other hand, had to raise children and take care of household tasks. Certainly this wasn't less important, but it required less muscle. Therefore, to attract the best male mate, women developed a desire to accentuate those characteristics most desirable to men. These include a petite frame and accentuated bosom and derriere. I imagine these types could easily be flipped if men were the ones who gave birth, but wouldn't men really just be women in the end? I feel we are trapped to have these two body types, because we need differentiation to reproduce. To have one androgynous body type would serve no purpose.  Also, I should add that these ideal types have been blown out of proportion by the media in the last century to unrealistic heights, but there is an explanation for them.

Therefore, I think that while there indeed is nothing wrong with striving for whatever body type you want, there also is nothing wrong with the stereotypical male and female image. When you see men and women striving for these bodies they are simply obeying their biological imperative. They may in fact be a bit outdated in today's increasingly post-modern society, but it's hard to ignore something so ingrained in the human psyche. It is designed to indicate the best genes and opportunity to pass on your traits to another generation. The real problem lies in the media, who have sensationalized these ideals to the extreme. Is there a solution to this? I don't think so, and I don't know if we need one. As I said before these ideal types serve a purpose. The best thing to do would try to have the media tone down their rhetoric, but by this point I think it's too late to affect change.

In Response to Jess McClean

Jess brought up the idea of women in sports and we discussed in class that society often has expected gender roles for each gender.  This story about Sam Gordon aired this past summer. Sam is a nine year old girl from Utah that plays organized tackle football in an all-male league.  Not only does she play, but she is exceptionally good at it too.  She broke many state youth football records while competing against boys nearly twice her size.  At the rate that she's been playing, she could legitimately pursue a career in professional football if she were to continue and progress.  Sam's story is interesting because of the gender roles society has laid out for us.  Imagine if Sam were to grow older and big enough where she was able to play in the NFL.  Would society be ready for a female football player, especially in a league full of men?  This issue came up previously when I believe it was Florida State University let their Women's Soccer Team goalie try out for the position of kicker on their football team.  She made the team I believe, but did not finish the season.  Examples like these are interesting to take note of considering the ideas we talked about in class.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oclLKHg9rsc

Ryan Chilelli

Too Much Exposure?

When looking at the video of the Mutter museum, I asked myself this question: Is showing the human body in a museum too much for society? With the background of stories of exposure by the people who had their “freakish” qualities shown to the public, when is it going too far? I believe that modern society does not view these exposures at the same level as society from the 1800s or earlier. People can be drawn from the variety of these qualities for their entertainment purposes. The video is a little outdated but I feel that there are not that many scientific studies that are based off of museums anymore. The museum is important in exposing diseases that scientists have found a way to treat but have they in the past few years? I don’t believe that showing these varieties to the public is good in helping the public gain awareness. Science has now taken a turn towards technology and seems to rarely use visual reference anymore. Should these museums become private for the science field or stay open for the public? 

Darren Pope