The reading Believing Is Seeing, states that "feats by women athletes who were presented as mature adults might force sports organizations and audiences to rethink their stereotypes of women's capabilities." I have seen over the years women's sports up and coming. There are more women beginning to participate in college, semi professional, and Olympic sports. I feel that even though there is a stereotype that says that women can only participate in sports that are not physical or that is a slower pace, I feel that women should be able to participate in any sport they would like regardless of contact level. I understand that men are stronger and the stereotypes are there to "protect" women, but should the player should be able to make that choice on their own. I think that the fact that as women get older their game changes is ridiculous.
Jessica McClean
Course blog for SUNY Fredonia HIST 375/AMST 399/WGST 377: History of Authority (Science, Medicine, and the "Deviant" Body), taught by professor Jeffry J. Iovannone, Spring 2013
Friday, February 22, 2013
The gendered "fit" body
When we briefly touched upon the expectations for athletes
yesterday it got me thinking about the different ways men and women view a
healthy body, how biological is use to create ideal and how the genders often
have different goals for a “fit body”. Generally it is evident by what each
does at the gym. And given the uproar about the new gym, it felt fitting. Having
been to the new gym and quite a few others I notice that the standard has been
holding true; women will be on cardio machines most of the time they spend at
the gym and will lift weights/ use machines or mats for a small portion of the
time. While men will possibly participate in cardio for a small period of time
and then lift weights most of the time they are there, a lot of the time I've noticed it is straight to the weights. Of course there are exceptions these
observations, but if you walked in the gym and took note of the number of woman
on cardio machines or the number of men lifting weights you would seen these
hold true. The expectation woman hold for themselves is to have a thin body,
usually when it comes to working out the method in which we tell others we are
doing well is often the weight we've lost. However, while weight can be a
factor for men it is often how much their lifting abilities have increased or
the various muscles that can be seen now. Why isn't it both ways? Why can’t the
genders want both, it’s healthy. There are quite a few men who do, but speaking
about women; most are opposed to have a lot of muscle. Often woman will say
they couldn't achieve muscle like men and I don’t feel that’s completely accurate,
women are much better at building lower body muscles while men are better at
building upper body. Okay so we can build muscle and yes, who doesn't want to be strong, and yes
muscle is good, but most woman just want to be toned and don’t want bulky
muscle because it makes them more masculine. Just as we can see thin males
without muscles as more masculine. Now I guess the question comes down to why
we view these specific bodies as what is perfect for our gender and who decided
it couldn't be more even?
-Joan W.
Thursday, February 21, 2013
A Note on Body Worlds
We talked Tuesday about Body Worlds and its similarities to the Museum in the video. I brought up how I visited the exhibit in Cleveland when I was younger, and I wanted to use my post this week to talk about it.
Body Worlds is a traveling exhibit that displays preserved bodies and their respective organs. It has received a lot criticism, but there has been a lot of praise for its displays of the inner workings of the human body. As I said before, my family and I visited the exhibit when I was young, and when we bought the tickets we weren't all that sure on what the exhibit was. Of course we were in for a shock.
As creepy and surreal looking at dead humans were, there was a certain educational value to it. I remember they had exhibits on the differences between athletes and smokers, but one of the more intriguing pieces was dedicated to the development of the unborn fetus from contraception to birth. As I kid, I was amazed by the transition of a single cell into human through real human examples. (This post was not meant to spark any debate on abortion or any of that, I am only describing what I saw.)
Some of the things I saw were grotesque. Obviously, my little brother was not able to appreciate some things as my parents and I could. There is definitely some shock value in the exhibit, and that is why it draws such a crowd. But in it I also saw the beauty of the human body and its inner-working miracles. Maybe it is an art piece, maybe it is a scientific exhibit, either way it provides insight to the bodies that we all reside in, and because of that I saw its worth.
Below is the website for the exhibit for any pics and info:
http://www.bodyworlds.com/en.html
Body Worlds is a traveling exhibit that displays preserved bodies and their respective organs. It has received a lot criticism, but there has been a lot of praise for its displays of the inner workings of the human body. As I said before, my family and I visited the exhibit when I was young, and when we bought the tickets we weren't all that sure on what the exhibit was. Of course we were in for a shock.
As creepy and surreal looking at dead humans were, there was a certain educational value to it. I remember they had exhibits on the differences between athletes and smokers, but one of the more intriguing pieces was dedicated to the development of the unborn fetus from contraception to birth. As I kid, I was amazed by the transition of a single cell into human through real human examples. (This post was not meant to spark any debate on abortion or any of that, I am only describing what I saw.)
Some of the things I saw were grotesque. Obviously, my little brother was not able to appreciate some things as my parents and I could. There is definitely some shock value in the exhibit, and that is why it draws such a crowd. But in it I also saw the beauty of the human body and its inner-working miracles. Maybe it is an art piece, maybe it is a scientific exhibit, either way it provides insight to the bodies that we all reside in, and because of that I saw its worth.
Below is the website for the exhibit for any pics and info:
http://www.bodyworlds.com/en.html
Running like a girl isn't such a bad thing
A lot
of very good points were brought up in class discussion today, whether you
agree with them or not they were good points.
That being said, I would like to discuss some points that Judith Lorber
attempts to make. I understand that this
article was written years ago but we are reading it now which makes it
relevant. Lorber says that Western
sports are aimed at men. Men may be
stronger and faster than women, but in some sports that seem to be dominated by
men, women dominate in reality. Riflery
for example is a segregated Olympic sport because women are more adept to firing
a rifle more accurately than men.
Why? It’s not because women have
steadier hands or better eye sight. It’s
because of their structural build.
Endurance running has also shown that women can be competitive with
men. In 2010 at the Hard Rock 100, a
100 mile running race, Diana Finkel finished in second place. In fact looking through the results of the
previous years, there is usually always a woman in the top 10 finishers. It’s only a matter of time before a women
finishes in first place. Women are
relatively new to running. At the 2012
Boston Marathon the winning male time was 2:12:40 while the first woman
finisher was 2:31:50. The women’s average
pace was 5:47 per mile while the men’s was 5:03 per mile. This may seem contradictory to my point, but
a women getting second in a major race compared to a women coming in nineteen
minutes after a man shows that in certain events women are just as good. Women have different strengths due to biology
not from a social construction. These
two sports aren’t widely watched and I do not think it’s because women are
pretty dominate it’s probably because they are not as entertaining as football
or soccer with fast paced action. So
while it may seem that women are kept down in many sports, there are activities
that women excel at.
That's Krissy Moehl running . . . in a skirt.
http://registration.baa.org/cfm_Archive/iframe_ArchiveSearch.cfm?mode=topfinishers&snap=49164180&
http://www.runnersworld.com/trail-runner-profiles/5-minutes-krissy-moehl
Artifact Presentation: "If Men Could Menstruate"
If Men Could
Menstruate
By: Gloria
Steinem
A white minority of the world has
spent centuries conning us into thinking that a white skin makes people
superior - even though the only thing it really does is make the more subject
to ultraviolet rays and to wrinkles. Male human beings have built whole
cultures around the idea that penis envy is "natural" to women -
though having such an unprotected organ might be said to make men vulnerable,
and the power to give birth makes womb envy at least as logical.
In short, the characteristics of
the powerful, whatever they may be, are thought to be better than the
characteristics of the powerless - and logic has nothing to do with it.
What would happen, for instance,
if suddenly, magically, men could menstruate and women could not?
The answer is clear -
menstruation would become an enviable, boast-worthy, masculine event:
Men would brag about how long and
how much.
Boys would mark the onset of
menses, that longed-for proof of manhood, with religious ritual and stag parties.
Congress would fund a National
Institute of Dysmenorrhea to help stamp out monthly discomforts.
Sanitary supplies would be
federally funded and free. (Of course, some men would still pay for the
prestige of commercial brands such as John Wayne Tampons, Muhammad Ali's
Rope-a-dope Pads, Joe Namath Jock Shields - "For Those Light Bachelor
Days," and Robert "Baretta" Blake Maxi-Pads.)
Military men, right-wing
politicians, and religious fundamentalists would cite menstruation
("men-struation") as proof that only men could serve in the Army
("you have to give blood to take blood"), occupy political office
("can women be aggressive without that steadfast cycle governed by the
planet Mars?"), be priest and ministers ("how could a woman give her
blood for our sins?") or rabbis ("without the monthly loss of
impurities, women remain unclean").
Male radicals, left-wing
politicians, mystics, however, would insist that women are equal, just
different, and that any woman could enter their ranks if she were willing to self-inflict
a major wound every month ("you MUST give blood for the revolution"),
recognize the preeminence of menstrual issues, or subordinate her selfness to
all men in their Cycle of Enlightenment. Street guys would brag ("I'm a
three pad man") or answer praise from a buddy ("Man, you lookin'
good!") by giving fives and saying, "Yeah, man, I'm on the rag!"
TV shows would treat the subject at length. ("Happy Days": Richie and
Potsie try to convince Fonzie that he is still "The Fonz," though he
has missed two periods in a row.) So would newspapers. (SHARK SCARE THREATENS
MENSTRUATING MEN. JUDGE CITES MONTHLY STRESS IN PARDONING RAPIST.) And movies.
(Newman and Redford in "Blood Brothers"!)
Men would convince women that
intercourse was more pleasurable at "that time of the month."
Lesbians would be said to fear blood and therefore life itself - though
probably only because they needed a good menstruating man.
Of course, male intellectuals
would offer the most moral and logical arguments. How could a woman master any
discipline that demanded a sense of time, space, mathematics, or measurement,
for instance, without that in-built gift for measuring the cycles of the moon
and planets - and thus for measuring anything at all? In the rarefied fields of
philosophy and religion, could women compensate for missing the rhythm of the
universe? Or for their lack of symbolic death-and-resurrection every month?
Liberal males in every field
would try to be kind: the fact that "these people" have no gift for
measuring life or connecting to the universe, the liberals would explain,
should be punishment enough.
And how would women be trained to
react? One can imagine traditional women agreeing to all arguments with a
staunch and smiling masochism. ("The ERA would force housewives to wound
themselves every month": Phyllis Schlafly. "Your husband's blood is
as sacred as that of Jesus - and so sexy, too!": Marabel Morgan.)
Reformers and Queen Bees would try to imitate men, and pretend to have a
monthly cycle. All feminists would explain endlessly that men, too, needed to
be liberated from the false idea of Martian aggressiveness, just as women
needed to escape the bonds of menses envy. Radical feminist would add that the
oppression of the non-menstrual was the pattern for all other oppressions
("Vampires were our first freedom fighters!") Cultural feminists
would develop a bloodless imagery in art and literature. Socialist feminists
would insist that only under capitalism would men be able to monopolize
menstrual blood . . . .
In fact, if men could menstruate,
the power justifications could probably go on forever.
If we let them.
Description and Analysis:
The artifact that I have chosen
to discuss for my presentation is the article “If Men Could Menstruate,” which
was originally published in Ms.
Magazine by Gloria Steinem. The writer proposes that if men were able to
menstruate, this monthly occurrence would be viewed as a positive
characteristic and would definitely not hold the same taboos that it does for
women. Steinem goes above and beyond to depict a world where men are capable of
menstruation and what this change would mean for gender and social norms. Gloria
Steinem is well-known for playing a big role in the second-wave of the feminist
movement. Through her involvement in Ms. Magazine
this article was able to be published in the first ever liberal feminist
magazine.
Weitz’s reading, “A History of Women’s
Bodies,” refers to “liberal feminists” as goal-oriented towards gaining
equality with men within social structures. This magazine was the only existing
one of its kind, where only women were writing and working for the magazine.
This magazine stood against so many women’s issues that are brought up within
Weitz’s article including: menstruation, abortion, childcare, job
opportunities, etc. I feel that “If Men Could Menstruate” will stimulate great
discussion surrounding women’s inferiority status and how the particular issue
of menstruation has been stigmatized by society because of its association with
women.
In Lorber’s article “Believing
Is Seeing” she states, “The moral imperatives of religion and cultural
representations reinforce the boundary lines among genders and ensure that what
is demanded, what is permitted, and what is tabooed for the people in each
gender is well-known and followed by most.” The cultural taboo surrounding
menstruation is continuously perpetuated because of the gender that is
connected to it. Steinem suggests if men were the one’s able to menstruate, would
this therefore imply that menstruation would no longer be considered inferior? This
interesting question raises concerns brought up by both Weitz and Lorber, women
are inherently inferior and therefore their bodies and what they do are also
considered to be lesser than men’s bodies.
“Women and Medicalization”,
written by Reissman, addresses a particular medicalized aspect of women, which
is birthing. But, there has also been a medicalization of menstruation as time
has gone on. Reissman considers something to be medicalized when it is looked
at as related to health and illness. It also must require medical intervention
in order to control the situation that has been termed deviant according to
social norms. Considering that menstruation can now be completely eliminated or
reduced to an occurrence of only 4 times a year due to new birth controls,
(i.e.; Seasonale, Seasonique, and Lybrel) it is obvious that menstruation has
been medicalized as a potential illness for women.
Discussion Questions:
1) Weitz says that her article is meant to
“illustrate how whenever women have fought to change ideas about their bodies
and to improve their situations, others have fought to keep them in their
places. This battle continues today.” Even after Steinem’s piece, which was
originally published in 1978 menstruation continues to be stigmatized. What do
you think about this taboo and how does Steinem’s article suggest things would
be different “if men could menstruate”?
2) Steinem states at the end of her piece, “If
men could menstruate, the power justifications would go on forever.” Lorber’s article covers this power
differential and how manliness is deemed superior and femaleness is considered
inferior. For example, male gymnasts are
trained to be physically strong while female gymnasts are praised for their
grace and small physique. How does Steinem’s piece depict cultural norms about
biological differences?
3) Riessman discusses medicalization of women
and how illness, like gender, has become socially constructed. Steinem seems to
illustrate men’s menstruation as anything but an illness. Why is it that
women’s issues are so often intervened with the medical field? In what ways has
menstruation become medicalized?
4) Do you see Steinem’s article as a gross over
exaggeration of social norms related to gender or do you believe that the way
she has implemented humor into a taboo subject allows the audience to look at
menstruation from a new perspective?
Wednesday, February 20, 2013
Freaks and Body Parts
It seems as though everything so far we have talked about related to the concept of freaks. With the documentary that we saw in class about the Mutter Museum, the narrator of the documentary was talking about the body parts as being freakish, or freaky. I honestly don't agree with this idea. We can see that in the earlier days that there were many interesting medical findings in the past. But just because someone had a unique medical condition, that doesn't make them a freak. Honestly I don't like the term freak at all. If I knew someone that had a unique medical condition, I wouldn't call that person a freak.I know some other people would call them freaks, but I think it is wrong to call them freaks.
-Courtney O'Donnell
-Courtney O'Donnell
Tuesday, February 19, 2013
The times they are a changin
When I was reading a particular piece for this week's readings I felt it necessary to talk about the evolution of women and the sports they play. Now to begin I would first want to mention that women were not excluded from any types of events that were more male oriented, but when they preformed in such sports they were considered more of novelty acts than well respected events which were represented by male athletes. Now to the actual reading which is Biology as Ideology by Judith Lorber I could help but think about the dramatic changes that have occurred for sporting events representing women. History can show us that a regular gym class in the 1950's and 60's would be seen as a male dominated area. Boys in gym classes could play such activities as basketball and gain an actual workout from it. Whereas the girls in the gym class were placed in a small section of gym where they could use their time for streching and aerobics. Now in our modern society we see that women's sports can be just as athletic as male sports. As well their is no sport in our modern day society which is dominated by males. Basketball, football, even bodybuilding is not for just males anymore. This dramatic change to the landscape of sporting events shows that perhaps our culture has changed in some way for the better. Even though equality is still a work in progress, equality in sporting events seems to be at an all time high. Now does this mean that women are completely free from discrimination at least in the athletics or do you believe that women are still being considered less than athletes and more of novality acts?
To give you an early history of women's involvement in sports I have provided a link to a time line of some of the earliest times in history documenting women and athletics:
http://www.northnet.org/stlawrenceaauw/timeline.htm
-William Webster
To give you an early history of women's involvement in sports I have provided a link to a time line of some of the earliest times in history documenting women and athletics:
http://www.northnet.org/stlawrenceaauw/timeline.htm
-William Webster
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)